Tom:
 She's gonna walk through that door
 The one she slammed ten years before
 And I won't hesitate
 It's all so long ago and late
 The one who got away
 Things got turned around
 ****ed-up mistakes that broke us down
 She said "I know you Tom,
 Knew I was doubting all along"
 The one who got away
 Didn't even try to make her stay
 Sara
 Say yes
 Sara
 You erase the rest
 Tom and Narrator:
 Man don't be a fool
 She's not coming back to you
 Tom:
 She's just stopping by
 One quick drink "Hello, Goodbye"
 The one who got away
 Didn't even try to make her stay
 But Sara
 Say yes
 Sara
 You erase them
 Sara
 Say yes
 Sara
 You erase them
 I had a dream of us in our sixties
 Was a cold winter night in New York City
 Walkin' down a cobblestone street
 Empty, but you were holding my hand
 Smiling at me and
 Tom, Sara, and Narrator:
 Snow was fallin' down
 And covering the ground
 Tom:
 And Sara
 there's another but she's not you
 Sara
 Girl, I need you
 Sara
 Come on, say yes
 Sara
 You erase the rest
 You erase the rest
 And I can hope, and want, and dream
 But she's taken and it's not going to be