The first time I walked in, it was raining
I closed my umbrella and I looked inside
The first time I walked in, there was no speaking
I walked to the counter and I ordered Chai
My heels went "clickity-clack" on the floorboards
Sitting at the table at the back, you were so bored
I wonder what you were thinking
I wonder what you thought of me
My tear stains all over the sweater that I got you
Wearing it now, it could never be brand new
I wonder what you were thinking that day
Remember when you told me I was pretty?
I was pretty, I was pretty
What a pity
What a pity that you're gone
You're gone
Remember when we sat here?
We were sitting
We were sitting at the table by the window
I closed my eyes and now I'm all alone
Earl Grey in my hands you'll never know
The second time I walked in, you were waving
I skipped on over and I smiled wide
We talked on forever
And you held both my hands as the sunlight glittered in the room
The clock went "clickity-clack" on the mint wall
Sitting at the table at the back, you were so dumb
I wonder what you were thinking, looking over at me
My lipstick all over the rim of the mug
I remember your laugh and I remember you crying
You crying
Remember when you told me I was pretty?
I was pretty, I was pretty
What a pity
What a pity that you're gone
You're gone
Remember when we sat here?
We were sitting
We were sitting at the table by the window
I closed my eyes and now I'm all alone
Earl Grey in my hands you'll never know
Drop the sugar cube into what's left of the sweet ghost of you
My love
My love, My love
My love, My love
Drowning in the mess I made
Tastes better than pink lemonade, my love
My love, My love
My love, My love
The last time I walked in, it was snowing
I skipped my order and I held my breath
And it felt so funny, to be alone like that
Sitting at the empty table made for two
Remember when you told me I was pretty?
I was pretty, I was pretty
What a pity
What a pity that you're gone
What a pity that you're gone
Remember when we sat here?
We were sitting
We were sitting at the table by the window
I closed my eyes and now I'm all alone
Earl Grey in my hands you'll never know
Drop the sugar cube into what's left of the sweet ghost of you
My love
My love, My love
My love, My love
Drowning in the mess I made
Tastes better than pink lemonade, my love
My love, My love
My love, My love